RDR perfect score?

Tell me what you think.

Dude, GTA was nothing compared to the calibre and size and awesomeness of this game. It's exponentially better than GTA without a doubt. If you read OXM (Offical Xbox Magazine) the highest rating is "11: The unicorn will never happen. Never." I think this could be the unicorn. I have never been so pumped for a game in my life and it's not just hype. RDR will be revolutionary.

It may get a perfect score but it won't be perfect.

I'm sorry but I just don't see it.

Lot's of 9.9's and 9.8's though.

I am hoping it will be a perfect score as many sites gave GTA4 a 10. But expectations rise over time and some get too high, but I am sure this game will be a 9.5 and up.

I am hoping for a yes.

From what I have seen yes, But until you have actually finished the game and done EVERYTHING it has in it, then you can't really tell..

hopefully it will be good enough for a 10. im hoping yes

Who gets a vote in it, the websites or the public?

i say maybe only because ppl hate it even if the slightest thing is wrong

the game looks amazing so i have to go with a yeeeessss!

i voted yes but until the games release you cant tell. im pretty sure that this game will blow gta 4 out of the water as RDR looks like the perfected version.

I think it will be a yes because how many sandbox games have you seen with all these extra things to do.

From what I've seen I'm thinking yes. Some sites just might give it a perfect score but there are others that will be very picky and give it like a 9.8 or something.

I can't remember where I read it but a reviewer said that it was a lot better than GTA IV, so... maybe D:

Doubt it. Reviewers always give a hard time when it comes to giving perfection because in all honesty nothing is perfect. Yeah GTA IV got a perfect and I love the game, but it is defintely not perfect. Maybe though, guess you never know

It's obviously subjective, but GTAIV really didn't deserve the score it received. GTAIV was perhaps a 75-80. A good game, sure, but not amazing by any means. The higher scores that GTAIV received were mostly due to the out of control expectations and hype that the game was receiving pre-release. It is because I am an aberrant western fan that I suspect that Red Dead Redemption will be better... and it will. I really did enjoy the gameplay mechanics and physics of GTAIV, so taking that base and painting it with a western template is a perfect match for my gaming tastes.

i bloody hope so. i have saved £50 for the special addition so it better be worth it!(Which it will be of course, its R* after all!)

I dunno, but I'm definitely betting on it. I just wish it was more publicized cause I'm afraid that it'll never be known to some who probably would have lost their social life over this like we are haha.

Western = perfect hehe